Friday, November 13, 2009

Unfair Competitive Advantage: What’s It All About, Aimee?

I just read this article written by Aimee Mullins, an accomplished track athlete and former President of the Women’s Sports Foundation, who runs with two woven carbon fiber Cheetah Legs. Her article is a dissection and refutation of “unfair competitive edge” arguments used against athletes with disabilities who want to compete against athletes who do not have disabilities.

Mullins sums up her argument:

“The crux of that question lays under the umbrella of ethics, which should indeed govern our rule structure within the competitive arena, but there's something in this story which specifically points toward a deep-seated fear, one we don't want to talk about in polite conversation, one which parallels historical instances of racial integration of sport and gender integration of sport. If we allow a person, one who we view as our inferior (in whatever way), to play with us, and then that person beats us, what does that say about us?”

Mullins makes the point that sport is based on gaining an advantage and asks the question, how do we separate gaining an advantage within the bounds of the rules we have agreed to in a sport and gaining an “unfair” advantage. And I would add, who gets to decide which is which? Few people would agree that all athletes who enter a contest have an equal chance to win. Each one has advantages and disadvantages based on genetic gifts from their parents, training regimens, access to the coaching and state of the art sports equipment, access to clean air and good nutrition, discrimination, financial resources, mental toughness and on and on.

Mullins asks the question, why are her Cheetah Legs seen as an unfair advantage in a race with athletes who run on their own legs when we do not disqualify athletes based on these other advantages? Why do we suddenly get all concerned about a “level playing field” when we know there is no such thing?

Mullins’ article focuses on athletes with disabilities, but the argument can be applied to other situations where we fret about competitive equity too. When intersex or transgender athletes want to compete in women’s sports, similar concerns are raised about unfair competitive advantages. We wrestled with these questions at length at the Transgender Think Tank a few weeks ago. One of our guiding principles was to “preserve the integrity” of women’s sport as we discussed policies that would enable transgender athletes to compete in their preferred gender (most people’s concerns focus on transgender or intersex women competing in women’s sports, not transgender or intersex men competing in men’s sports though there are issues there as well).

When women competitors take the field, dive into the pool or run onto the court, the range of differences among them is wide. Competitive equity is a relative term. Using Aimee’s argument, how do we decide when a transgender or intersex woman has an unfair competitive advantage and why do we focus on her potential advantages when we do not worry about the advantages or disadvantages of the other women in the competition? It’s because we see these variations as normal. We expect them. I won because I am taller, stronger, more skilled, more determined, I worked harder. I deserved to win. Our challenge is to stretch our vision of what is normal to include competitors who have been excluded based on fears and prejudices or our desire to maintain a sense of superiority. Excluding athletes of color, women, lesbians and gay men, people with disabilities, transgender and intersex athletes have historically and still are too often based on these fears and prejudices. The similarities among the arguments used to justify this exclusion or limitation is surprisingly similar regardless of the group being targeted.

Interesting connections, don’t you think?


kristenworley said...

It actually goes way beyond this, and core to the problem is our societies needs of which sport is a small window there of... to put people into boxes and labels attached to them.

It is our societies fascination with sex and sexuality - If you think of the Caster Semenya issue and other women who have fallen before her, little has to do with reality of intersex and competitive performance. Your missing what is really going on here by using words as transgender/intersex to draw your conclusions -

Example - Usain Bolt and Mike Phelps get to compete - are you saying because Caster is a woman, and that she has unique characteristics as a woman though she did not set a World's meet record nor a womens 800m record. Women have run faster before her, that she is ineligible to compete?

Where as, we accept Usain Bolt and Mike Phelps performances, blowing away the fields of which they compete and continually applaud their performances saying "Go faster even..." They have unique features and competitive advantage against their male competitors, but they are NOT sex or genetically tested?

They get a pass because they are men?

If you are to apply this question to Caster you must take a broader position of these men too. Stop focusing on her Inter-sex type, it is fogging the reality of what is really going on here. Stop using transgender/intersex in discussion because using Caster as an example, intersexed or not is not the issue, it is how we do sport - and focus on the truth... We harm human difference solely based on our own ignorance.

I would suggest further reading - Canadian Academy of Sport Medicine Newsletter, pages 11-13, October 2009 issue that reflects on this.


Language and proper dialogue is key to making more understanding and inclusive sport.

handicapping forum said...

this is indeed a story with many things to consider, i cannot say for sure what is fair and what is not but this is a touching subject and im glad you brought it up

negocios rentables said...

hello, i would like to read more about this interesting topic beacuase it is really interesting.

Best brain booster pills said...

If we allow a person, one who we view as our inferior

hcg said...

The post is very nicely written and it contains many useful facts. I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement. Thanks for sharing with us.

Vimax increase semen volume pills said...

It was great pleasure to read your entire post and the discussion either.

GenFX dietary anti aging supplement said...

The crux of that question lays under the umbrella of ethics, which should indeed govern our rule structure within the competitive arena.

Proextender penis extender device review said...

Thanks will not just be sufficient, for the exceptional clarity in your writing. I will immediately grab your rss feed to stay privy of any updates.

Compare the best penis extenders said...

The post seems interesting. I have never heard something like this before.

Best Infant Car Seats Reviews said...

I think you really made your point here and i think its a very good one sir.

Trichozed said...

The way of presentation is really impressive.This is the best way of describing something.

Anonymous said...

Hi there everyone, it's my first go to see at this site, and piece of writing is in fact fruitful in favor of me, keep up posting these types of articles or reviews.
my site - free webcam chatroom

Anonymous said...

Malaysia & Singapore & brunei ultimate on the internet blogshop for wholesale & quantity korean accessories, earrings,
earstuds, necklace, rings, trinket, hair & bracelet add-ons.

Deal 35 % wholesale price cut. Ship Worldwide
Feel free to surf my homepage My clean pc scam

Anonymous said...

Attractive part of content. I just stumbled upon your
blog and in accession capital to claim that I get in fact loved account your weblog
posts. Any way I'll be subscribing in your feeds and even I achievement you get admission to constantly quickly.
Visit my page :: washington state unemployment website

Anonymous said...

I am actually glad to glance at this webpage posts which includes tons of useful
information, thanks for providing such information.
My weblog :: click through the up coming internet page

Interactive Response System said...

I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, superb blog!

Anonymous said...

For newest news you have to pay a visit world wide web and on
world-wide-web I found this website as a most excellent web site
for newest updates.
Here is my blog : web hosting delhi

Audience Response System Rental said...

I was really excited to go over every lines of your review. Superb work! Can't wait to read more of your blogs. Keep it up!

Anonymous said...

This is very attention-grabbing, You are an overly professional blogger.

I have joined your feed and look forward to in quest of more of
your great post. Additionally, I have shared your web site in my social networks

my weblog :: sniper flash games

Anonymous said...

Hello there! I could have sworn I've been to this site before but after looking at some of the posts I realized it's new to me.
Regardless, I'm definitely happy I stumbled upon it and I'll be book-marking it and checking back regularly!

my site: topsportsmodel

Anonymous said...

My brother suggested I may like this blog. He was once totally right.
This submit actually made my day. You cann't believe just how a lot time I had spent for this information! Thank you!

Have a look at my web-site: taobao agent

Anonymous said...

It is perfect time to make some plans for the future and it's time to be happy. I've learn
this submit and if I may just I wish to counsel you some interesting issues or tips.
Maybe you could write next articles referring
to this article. I wish to read even more issues about it!

Also visit my blog taobao agent

Anonymous said...

It's amazing to pay a visit this site and reading the views of all colleagues concerning this paragraph, while I am also keen of getting knowledge.

Here is my website:

Anonymous said...

I'm gone to inform my little brother, that he should also pay a quick visit this blog on regular basis to obtain updated from most up-to-date news.

my web page -

Anonymous said...

An outstanding share! I've just forwarded this onto a colleague who had been doing a little research on this. And he actually ordered me lunch due to the fact that I stumbled upon it for him... lol. So allow me to reword this.... Thanks for the meal!! But yeah, thanx for spending time to talk about this subject here on your web page.

Feel free to surf to my weblog - Teen Porn

Anonymous said...

Excellent blog here! Additionally your site a lot up fast!
What host are you using? Can I am getting your affiliate hyperlink on your host?

I desire my web site loaded up as fast as yours lol

Check out my web blog ::

Anonymous said...

Hmm it seems like your website ate my first comment (it was
super long) so I guess I'll just sum it up what I had written and say, I'm thoroughly enjoying your blog.
I too am an aspiring blog blogger but I'm still new to everything. Do you have any points for rookie blog writers? I'd certainly appreciate

My site nude sex teens

Anonymous said...

No matter if some one searches for his essential thing,
therefore he/she wants to be available that in detail, therefore that thing is maintained
over here.

Feel free to surf to my webpage; free teem sex videos

Anonymous said...

It's not my first time to go to see this web site, i am browsing this web site dailly and get good information from here daily.

Here is my website; xvideos (

Audience Response System said...

The following tips tips are fantastic. Which i enjoy brainstorming about catchy subject lines. Often it can be challenging, but we need to do might know about want to do – please our readers!

audience response software said...

Hmmm Many person searching about that now they will find enough resources by your post....Thanks for sharing

Stephanie Smith said...

hard was it to build your blog? Could someone like me, a newbie do it? I really wanna to write in my site something like this. Just for your info your home page seem broken when I visiting using FF.lways been freely available from bookshops and dealerships, as well as on the Internet, but the major problem has been that they tend to be pretty expensive.

Stephanie Smith said...

I think one of your advertisements caused my internet browser to resize, you might want to put that on your blacklist.

finestglasses said...

Therefore, many night clubs have begun using polycarbonate glasses to serve drinks to customers.

sherry jiang said...

shop online for thousands of Taps, Kitchen Taps, Bathroom Taps, Sinks and Plumbing Fixtures at, sinks, bathroom, kitchen and shower fixtures. FREE SHIPPING on most items. Same day shipping on in stock items

sherry jiang said...

shop online for thousands of Taps, Kitchen Taps, Bathroom Taps, Sinks and Plumbing Fixtures at, sinks, bathroom, kitchen and shower fixtures. FREE SHIPPING on most items. Same day shipping on in stock items.